Separate Transport Qualification from Acceptance Aggregation

  • Status: accepted

  • Date: 2026-07-31

Context and Problem Statement

The acceptance aggregate previously embedded the complete transport evidence graph already published by transport-qualification-result.v1. This created two owners for channel observations, causal chains, trace evidence, and their verdict semantics.

Decision Drivers

  • One canonical owner for each evidence model

  • Independent transport qualification

  • Small, digest-addressed aggregate documents

  • Reuse across single-domain and multi-domain products

Considered Options

  • Keep both complete representations synchronized

  • Extract shared JSON Schema definitions while retaining duplicate documents

  • Reference the transport result from the acceptance aggregate

Decision Outcome

transport-qualification-result.v1 remains the sole owner of transport evidence and its verdict. acceptance-aggregate.v1 contains per-domain results and, when available, the transport result identifier, digest, and status. The aggregate status is derived from the domain and transport statuses.

Consequences

  • Transport evidence is validated once and reused by digest.

  • Aggregation no longer copies channels, traces, or causal chains.

  • Consumers compose the final aggregate from domain results and an optional transport qualification.