Separate Transport Qualification from Acceptance Aggregation¶
Status: accepted
Date: 2026-07-31
Context and Problem Statement¶
The acceptance aggregate previously embedded the complete transport evidence
graph already published by transport-qualification-result.v1. This created
two owners for channel observations, causal chains, trace evidence, and their
verdict semantics.
Decision Drivers¶
One canonical owner for each evidence model
Independent transport qualification
Small, digest-addressed aggregate documents
Reuse across single-domain and multi-domain products
Considered Options¶
Keep both complete representations synchronized
Extract shared JSON Schema definitions while retaining duplicate documents
Reference the transport result from the acceptance aggregate
Decision Outcome¶
transport-qualification-result.v1 remains the sole owner of transport
evidence and its verdict. acceptance-aggregate.v1 contains per-domain
results and, when available, the transport result identifier, digest, and
status. The aggregate status is derived from the domain and transport
statuses.
Consequences¶
Transport evidence is validated once and reused by digest.
Aggregation no longer copies channels, traces, or causal chains.
Consumers compose the final aggregate from domain results and an optional transport qualification.